Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...6465666768...349
26 Mar, 2016
2016-3-26 3:06:31 PM UTC
So I take it this is THE edition to own (sans jacket). Any guesses on final price given the condition?
27 Mar, 2016
2016-3-27 5:17:58 AM UTC

Tapuvae wrote:
So I take it this is THE edition to own (sans jacket). Any guesses on final price given the condition?

Less than 5,000, but hard to say with these, to be honest, as you only need a couple of people who really want one (or one who does and a shill) and the price can end up quite different than on a different day with a different set of bidders. Worth noting is that all the activity is only between a small number of bidders.

Makes no sense to me that people bid days before the auction ends. Also, you could buy a better copy on Abe for GBP 5000, so if it goes over that, the buyer has made a mistake.
27 Mar, 2016 (edited)
2016-3-27 12:52:04 PM UTC
I think the seller would be very happy to get the latest bids for this book, £3900, final sale was for £4300.

Condition is important for copies without dust-jackets, even if the cloth covering and the boards are nearly always in poor condition, but this book does have serious condition problems on the inside of the book, which the seller has shown in the photos of the item.
27 Mar, 2016
2016-3-27 8:21:17 PM UTC

Trotter wrote:
I think the seller would be very happy to get the latest bids for this book, £3900.

Condition is important for copies without dust-jackets, even if the cloth covering and the boards are nearly always in poor condition, but this book does have serious condition problems on the inside of the book, which the seller has shown in the photos of the item.


I agree - I had personally been quite surprised to see it go as high as it already has. With eBay, you always have to take things with a small pinch of salt, though. Amazing how many things "sell" and then are back on the market from the same seller a few weeks later.
28 Mar, 2016
2016-3-28 11:15:38 PM UTC

Stu wrote:

Trotter wrote:
I think the seller would be very happy to get the latest bids for this book, £3900.

Condition is important for copies without dust-jackets, even if the cloth covering and the boards are nearly always in poor condition, but this book does have serious condition problems on the inside of the book, which the seller has shown in the photos of the item.


I agree - I had personally been quite surprised to see it go as high as it already has. With eBay, you always have to take things with a small pinch of salt, though. Amazing how many things "sell" and then are back on the market from the same seller a few weeks later.

Final resting place of GBP 4,300, which is about 1,000 more than I expected at the very the start of the auction. The buyer has a huge feedback number (20,000+), so thinking probably purchased by a dealer. Wonder if it will come back on the market with the tipped in newspaper removed and some "sophistications" like facsimile jackets and a traycase...
29 Mar, 2016
2016-3-29 6:17:38 AM UTC
Effectively missing one of the volumes (easy enough to find on eBay fairly cheaply these days), but the box looks to be in good condition and they don't turn up all that often. Might be worth someone buying with the expectation that they get a replacement TT elsewhere. The texture of the box looks a tiny bit different than my copy, but that might be the light (although there are certainly two different variants of this set).

eBay Item #131757447539
4 Apr, 2016
2016-4-4 7:25:40 AM UTC
Damn you Stu!

BH
4 Apr, 2016
2016-4-4 7:32:33 AM UTC

Khamûl wrote:
Damn you Stu!

BH

Hee Hee. I'm surprised you don't already have this set - or are you hoarding?

I've removed the post :)
4 Apr, 2016
2016-4-4 9:13:54 PM UTC
Ok, reposting now the auction has finished (and assuming Khamul was not the purchaser).

Very surprised at the final price of this one (£109.77).

eBay Item #231890528147
4 Apr, 2016
2016-4-4 9:19:55 PM UTC
How do you know I haven't been hoarding money under my mattress for this very auction?

BH
1...6465666768...349
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us