Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...2930313233...274
9 Aug, 2011 (edited)
2011-8-9 7:40:27 PM UTC
I know that Khamul likes bargain Silm's

I think this item possibly does not fit the bill (£50, no dust jacket and a book club copy)

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/J-R-R-TOLKI ... em415c533a92#ht_500wt_922




It is £40 today, what a bargain
9 Aug, 2011
2011-8-9 9:55:36 PM UTC
If all those pages were blank --then yeh, bargain! But, the seller ain't wellnghall! (--& I'd hope he'd offer me that copy before bunging it on eBay.)

BH
10 Aug, 2011 (edited)
2011-8-10 6:37:56 PM UTC
This is, unlike most eBay descriptions that I list, a rare item, but I question the slipcase description looking at the picture (shown below)

Lord of the Rings - Alan Lee - Centenary Ed. - 1992 in slipcase £269.90 Buy it Now

All three books are in very good condition. All spines faultless and tight. Dustjackets not price clipped and all in very good condition with only minimal wear (The Two Twoers even in near mint condition). Only the slipcase shows clears signs of use and wear and is only in acceptable condition with scratches and rubbing off to corners. But since there have only been about 100 slipcased editions been issued according to Peter Collier from tolkienlibrary it is save to say this is rare!

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated
Seller: the_merp_shop
(1100)
Ended Aug 19, 2011
This item ended more than 90 days ago






Looking at the picture below, do people think this is acceptable (in fact is acceptable a correct term for books or slipcases)??

10_4e42cfed944d2.jpg 450X600 px
10 Aug, 2011 (edited)
2011-8-10 7:02:43 PM UTC
Poor, (G-), Good, (G+), (VG-), VG, (VG+), (NF), & Fine --there ain't no place for acceptable Trotter.

That aside, I think the term "acceptable" is the equivalent to the bottom of the grading scale i.e. poor. If this slipcase is not actually detached/split (which it looks like it might be), and only bashed, then it might correctly still be described as G; with qualification.

It is rare though. Well, so says that boy Peter...

BH
10 Aug, 2011
2011-8-10 7:10:32 PM UTC
Khamul, would you agree with me that Poor (G-) would describe the slipcase above. (It is very bashed)
10 Aug, 2011
2011-8-10 7:17:35 PM UTC
Sorry, I was editing while you posted.

Aye, G- would be fair enough. There's another one for you: fair.

BH
13 Aug, 2011
2011-8-13 12:33:54 PM UTC
This one is very strange, a first edition library book (ROTK 3rd Imp 1957), but laminated in a second edition dust-wrapper, 9 years later at least and from another copy of the book????

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated
Seller: michaelowillis
(776)
Ended Aug 20, 2011
This item ended more than 90 days ago


13 Aug, 2011
2011-8-13 6:02:21 PM UTC
I noticed that too Trotter, but just couldn't muster the effort to post it. Some people have too much time on their hands...

BH
19 Aug, 2011
2011-8-19 2:05:05 PM UTC
I'm sure a lot of you have noticed the 2nd UK Impression of the Hobbit that is listed on ebay. Also some of you may have noticed that some or most of the photo's were taken by myself some years ago. The link to the auction is:
This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated
Seller: osborneda
(9)
Ended Aug 25, 2011
This item ended more than 90 days ago


The reason I'm posting this notice, the seller indicates the book is in the original cloth with repairs to the spine tips. Then the photo's of mine, show that book, but not the exterior. The photo's that have been added after my request show a fully rebound copy, which also appears to have been one that I had rebound, by the small JRRT monogram on the spine versus the runes. I just wanted to point out that something is very wrong on this auction. It may be legit, but something is a bit hinky. The seller has not answered my questions about whether it is rebound or not, says to read the description (mine) and then goes and posts photo's of the fully rebound copy. Just wanted to warn anyone who might be considering bidding on this auction. Photo's of the original 'repaired' cover are attached.

David


609_4e4e6c9800c75.jpg 2192X1519 px

609_4e4e6d8778b74.jpg 1992X1464 px
19 Aug, 2011
2011-8-19 5:17:13 PM UTC
This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated
Seller: osborneda
(9)
Ended Aug 25, 2011
This item ended more than 90 days ago


The Hobbit - First Edition Second Impression 1937

Starting price $3400 Buy it now $5600


Additionally, you will see in one of the pictures a note with JRR Tolkiens's signature dated June 1973. Now I have never had this signature verified but it is possible it is his true signature as Tolkien Died September 1973. Eitherway, this comes with the book.

or it was produced on an Inkjet by dunedain

1...2930313233...274
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us