Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...5859606162...274
24 Jun, 2012
2012-6-24 11:56:44 AM UTC
Surprise surprise --it's alan-53!

This sellers listings are really quite funny. The items sold, in general, I don't have a problem with; the prices are a little on the high side; but the listings themselves are full of garbage.

I have been collecting books and music items for over 35 years and have amassed an enormous collection with many duplicates. I do not subscribe to "grading" as it is so subjective and most of the "graders" truly have no clue! Therefore I'll simply describe things in normal English!

Some pictures of the item would save everyone the bother. The seller then goes on to describe the book as "GOOD", as if this doesn't have any context in the grading of books. If they don't subscribe to grading, avoiding bookgrading terms would be a good place to start.

This is a vintage softcover book in extremely GOOD condition. The cover has come partially away from the spine in a few spots but there are no loose pages and the rest of the binding is solid. Other than that the book shows very minimal shelfwear from handling. As mentioned above, this is a stated First Printing from 1969. Don't pass this one up as you may never see it again!

As garm points out: you'll easily "see" this again. Ironically, the book does sound like a bookgrading "Good", what with the cover partially coming away from the spine. But without pictures all of this is pretty useless anyway.

For over a decade, I have sold tens of thousands of items on eBay and have only received a handful of complaints about the accuracy in my descriptions...

With descriptions like...

Not the Exact Book but Exact Same Cover for Reference

it's hard to argue one way or the other!

BH
24 Jun, 2012
2012-6-24 5:25:28 PM UTC
He has taken out the old nonsense about how some dealers describe books as rare, when they are not, pots and black kettles come to mind.
25 Jun, 2012
2012-6-25 9:13:21 AM UTC
It's not even as if this is the first publication of these poems of Tolkien's - goodness knows what the level of hype would be, if he ever got hold of a copy of 'Winter's Tales for Children'.
26 Jun, 2012
2012-6-26 7:47:08 PM UTC
And now for something completely different.

Hobbit related cufflinks might actually be cool, done right. These, however, make me feel like zombie Hobbits are going to come out of my basement and try to eat my brains...


**AWESOME** Sterling Silver The Hobbit Book Cufflinks - FREE SHIPPING and BOX

$89.82
End Date: Friday Jul-6-2012 3:54:48 PDT
Buy It Now for only: $89.82

29 Jun, 2012
2012-6-29 7:13:13 PM UTC
Someone has an odd notion of what constitutes 'fine condition'.

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated
Seller: 2buyor2sell321
(600)
Ended Jul 5, 2012
This item ended more than 90 days ago




4 Jul, 2012
2012-7-4 5:27:22 PM UTC
Yes, it's an unusual item. But if they want it to sell, they might be advised to put up some slightly better photos ...
This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated
Seller: queman786
(291)
Ended Jul 10, 2012
This item ended more than 90 days ago


- wellinghall

4 Jul, 2012
2012-7-4 5:33:24 PM UTC
I got a similar set... triple signed! And loving it...
4 Jul, 2012
2012-7-4 6:42:36 PM UTC
I might have to stop reading your posts, Beren; they just get me jealous!

- wellinghall
4 Jul, 2012
2012-7-4 6:59:03 PM UTC
I stopped listening to his stories years ago!

BH
4 Jul, 2012
2012-7-4 8:33:10 PM UTC
oops... sorry... but it is a lovely set. I like this edition a lot, but it is hard to find it in a fine state, especially since the books don't fit very well in the slipcase most sets are having not so nice boxes.
1...5859606162...274
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us