Login

Or
Register Now


Already have an account?
Username:

Password:

Remember me

Lost Your Password?
Main Menu
Collector's Guide Table of Contents
Recent Visitors

Karl
7 minutes ago

Stu
16 minutes ago

Khamûl
45 minutes ago

laurel
2 hours 15 minutes ago

wellinghall
3 hours 26 minutes ago

Laurin666
3 hours 36 minutes ago

Findegil
3 hours 40 minutes ago

Jlong
19 hours 37 minutes ago

Browsing this Thread:   1 Anonymous Users



(1) 2 »


Is the old Silmarrillion in BOLT the same as the new one?
Just popping in
Joined:
2009/1/21 10:22
Group:
Shirefolk
Posts: 10
Offline
Is the old Sillmarrillion in BOLT the same as the new one?

Eric The Red

Posted on: 2009/1/23 11:55

Edited by Khaml on 2013/4/24 12:58:52
Edited by Khaml on 2013/4/24 13:32:36


Re: Is the old Sillmarrillion in BOLT the same as the new one?
Shirrif
Joined:
2007/8/16 4:56
From Scotland
Group:
Shirefolk
Fellowship
Shirrif
Posts: 1522
Offline
Have a wee read of those 12 books, and perhaps it will be a little clearer... No, seriously, you'll need to read the HoME; all of it .

BH

Posted on: 2009/1/23 14:30
_________________
You drive a hard bargain – you can have it for £10 all-in – one consolation (for you) is that you do not have to hear the cries of my children, for bread...


Re: Is the old Sillmarrillion in BOLT the same as the new one?
Just popping in
Joined:
2009/1/21 10:22
Group:
Shirefolk
Posts: 10
Offline
I take it that means no?

Eric

Posted on: 2009/2/2 19:27


Re: Is the old Sillmarrillion in BOLT the same as the new one?
Home away from home
Joined:
2008/8/10 2:07
From Queenstown, New Zealand
Group:
Shirefolk
Fellowship
Posts: 621
Offline
Yep, that means "no". The HoME is largely about the evolution of Tolkien's middle-earth related writings. It wouldn't make much sense to print an identical Silmarillion as part of HoME. I personally don't find BoLT particularly interesting (and I'm surprised that HoME ever made it past that volume). I really enjoyed everything from 'The Return of the Shadow' onwards, but can happily leave the first 5 volumes on the shelf with only the occasional browse...

Stu

Posted on: 2009/2/2 20:14


Re: Is the old Sillmarrillion in BOLT the same as the new one?
Shirrif
Joined:
2007/8/16 4:56
From Scotland
Group:
Shirefolk
Fellowship
Shirrif
Posts: 1522
Offline
Indeed, the answer is basically no. I think if you want to put the published Silmarillion in context, you really have to read HoME; altho' the Hx LotRs is perhaps not essential.

Funny Stu, I think (I'm guessing tho', since I was a small child when this series first came out!) most people when the series came out quite like BoLTs; and were quite disappointed at some of the later books. Perhaps because the BoLTs books can be viewed (and read) as stand alone volumes; and don't 'interfere' with the published Silmarillion so much as some of the later volumes do.

Personally I'm the least interested (hard to say that!; still very interested...) in the volumes that cover LotRs, from a 'Middle-earth' perspective i.e. the are really (to me) primary world texts, showing Tolkien the author; very interesting just like Rateliff's Hx Hobbit. But Shaping, MR, Jewels, & Peoples really have an abundance of 'new' material so to speak. These (in my mind) sit in a hazy, indistinct world between primary world Tolkien (biography, author), and secondary world Tolkien (Middle-earth).

This cross-over between primary and secondary reaches it most complex in these later volumes: this 'soup' of redactors, translations, oral tradition, texts, 'lost' texts, multiple texts, history, conflicting versions, condensed story, authorship, editorship, publication etc etc -something which I feel plays out in the real history of the published Silmarillion i.e. the work of father & son (and Kay!). Which I suppose strikes at the heart (if my stab at explaining why I think I like Tolkien made any sense!) of why I'm totally obsessed with The Silmarillion .

BH

Posted on: 2009/2/3 4:40
_________________
You drive a hard bargain – you can have it for £10 all-in – one consolation (for you) is that you do not have to hear the cries of my children, for bread...



(1) 2 »



You can view topic.
You cannot start a new topic.
You cannot reply to posts.
You cannot edit your posts.
You cannot delete your posts.
You cannot add new polls.
You can vote in polls.
You cannot attach files to posts.
You cannot post without approval.

[Advanced Search]