Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

12

Lord of the rings trilogy

11 Jan, 2018
2018-1-11 4:33:27 AM UTC

I have a copy of the lord of the rings trilogy in one book. I cannot find a picture of my book or any information on it except that it maybe was printed in 1973. Can anyone give me more information on it and how much it is worth? Photos are attached. Thanks. Here's a link to see the photos. https://www.ksl.com/classifieds/listing/50710344
11 Jan, 2018 (edited)
2018-1-11 6:07:02 AM UTC
http://www.tolkienbooks.net/php/details.php?reference=45300

That's the one volume paperback edition from 1973, the 13th impression. It's a common edition and there are plenty to be found on eBay, AbeBooks and elsewhere. It certainly wouldn't be worth more than $10 USD unless it was in really nice condition. The 1st impressions from 1968 can go for quite a bit more, but later impressions like this aren't as 'collectible'. Still... in my opinion it's a great edition with that classic Baynes artwork.
11 Jan, 2018
2018-1-11 3:22:10 PM UTC
I have a similar edition, only it's hardcover:

247_5a5781158d314.png 480X640 px
11 Jan, 2018
2018-1-11 3:22:53 PM UTC
Oh, and signed.


247_5a57814ab432b.png 480X640 px
11 Jan, 2018
2018-1-11 3:23:52 PM UTC
Anyone have any idea what this might fetch these days?
11 Jan, 2018 (edited)
2018-1-11 4:21:39 PM UTC
I think my signed 1968 paperback is about £5000, but it is just signed and not inscribed, and is the 1st printing, not sure if the inscription decreases the value in this case.

What do people think about inscriptions, do they add or decrease value on a J.R.R. Tolkien signed item?

10_5a578efad6d3c.jpg 2197X1913 px
11 Jan, 2018
2018-1-11 4:43:46 PM UTC
I'd agree with Trotter's value estimate.

For inscriptions, my personal opinion is that it adds a bit more confidence in authenticity (more handwriting to analyze, some hint of history for provenance). I don't think it adds value per se unless the inscription itself is to someone "important" ie has meaning to third parties, not just the one it is signed to.

This is for Tolkien signed items, of course. For living authors, I feel that inscriptions subtract value for anyone not the recipient (again unless to someone "important"). I still get my books inscribed to me when I do meet authors, though, as I value the memory/interaction more than the resale value, personally.
11 Jan, 2018
2018-1-11 5:28:08 PM UTC
I have some supporting provenance documents from the previous owner, so in this case I think the inscription is actually a good thing.

I also find it poignant that it was inscribed on July 15th, 1973 — less than two months before Tolkien died....
11 Jan, 2018
2018-1-11 5:29:11 PM UTC
That's a beautiful signature there, Trotter!
11 Jan, 2018
2018-1-11 5:46:32 PM UTC
I strongly suspect that this:

Iain Torrance

is the Iain Torrance to whom my copy was inscribed. He says his father was a friend of Tolkien; and the father of the aforelinked Iain Torrance:

Thomas F. Torrance

was at Oriel College in 1939-40.

247_5a57a2f142bc8.jpg 2480X3231 px
12
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us