Register Now

Already have an account?


Remember me

Lost Your Password?
Main Menu
Collector's Guide Table of Contents
Recent Visitors

2 hours 56 minutes ago

5 hours 50 minutes ago

7 hours 45 minutes ago

8 hours 34 minutes ago

9 hours 31 minutes ago

10 hours 38 minutes ago

12 hours 6 minutes ago

23 hours 42 minutes ago

Two Page Handwritten and Signed Letter From Tolkien Up For Auction Through June 18th

| Filed under: Collecting NewsUrulöké | June 5, 2014 @ 9:36 am (Views: 10589)
Doris Sykes Tolkien Signed Letter Page 1
Doris Sykes Tolkien Signed Letter Page 2
Doris Sykes Tolkien Signed Letter Page 3
Doris Sykes Tolkien Signed Letter Page 4

[Update]: This item appears to have been withdrawn at the last moment, I assume because it failed to meet an invisible reserve.

RR Auction has a two page (both sides) handwritten and signed letter from J. R. R. Tolkien up for auction, and it is an outstanding example of his handwriting and signature. It has a postscript as well, with his shortened initials-only signature as well. The letter itself is undated, but based on the content it appears to have been written around 1956.

The letter itself was sent to Doris Sykes, an artist who had sent some illustrations for The Lord of the Rings to Tolkien and inquired if he was interested in using them for an illustrated edition. Tolkien was clearly impressed with her artwork and expressed interest in buying some himself, when finances allowed.

This is one of two letters sold at Christies in June 2013 - those two letters realized £15,000 ($23,505) at that time.

A brief extract from the letter:

“I have done nothing further in the matter, since the publishers are not at present inclined to consider any edition illustrated or more deluxe and costly than the one just issued…I have shown your drawings to other ‘readers’ & the response has been good; though most agree that the best way of doing hobbits is to make them absolutely ordinary human beings (except for a neat goatee or buskin of hair), and not too childlike, round-eyed etc.... I should be v. pleased to see any further drawings you make; though I cannot encourage any great hopes of your labour being rewarded in a practical way in the near future.”

Also, as a postscript Tolkien added the following note:

“Except that—if and when I get any money from the book after the vast costs are defrayed: I have had none at all yet—I like some of the drawings so much that I should like to consider asking you to allow me to purchase some for myself, in the event of an illustrated edition being indefinitely postponed.”

Item 520
Sale ends June 18, 2014
Current bid at $5826 (as of June 5th, 2014)


  1. Comment by Trotter:

    No question that this is a genuine letter, but if I look at the signature on the third page, no dots under the initials, or after his surname, which is unusual but now not always to be expected.

  2. Comment by Urulöké:

    A good point Trotter. Partially why having excellent provenance (or in this case, an overabundance of handwriting that would be impossible to forge) to make sure you are getting the real signature.

    Speaking of overabundance, the auction house (RR) has an estimate on this of $30-35,000 for the letter. Is it just me or are letter prices skyrocketing the past year or two? Two or three years ago, a letter like this would go for maybe a few thousand dollars. Ten years ago letters were usually under a thousand dollars. At this rate a letter such as this will sell for more than a signed first edition Hobbit in another year or two! (Mostly joking. I hope.)

Leave a comment

Sorry, you must be logged in to post a comment.

Tolkien Collecting News Archive
© 2016 TolkienGuide.com and respective authors. Contact Us