Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

By Max
Just can't stay away

Lotr first edition sizes

13 Aug, 2023
2023-8-13 9:40:10 AM UTC

Hello everyone,
I'm looking for help regarding sizes of the different impressions of LOTR UK first edition.

I know some are smaller (i.e. FOTR second impression), I'd like to know if their sizes are listed somewhere or at least if anyone here is able to point out the odd ones.

I'm asking cause I'd like to try acquiring early impressions and I'd love them to be of similar size

Many thanks,
Max
13 Aug, 2023
2023-8-13 9:57:52 AM UTC
To my knowledge, the shorter ones concern only Fellowship of the Ring. The shorter ones are 2nd impression, 3rd impression and the first batch of the 7th impression.
13 Aug, 2023
2023-8-13 10:20:38 AM UTC
I'm not sure it applies only to FOTR, look at this link:

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated
Seller: junescollectables
(2643)
Ended Aug 22, 2023
This item ended more than 90 days ago


TTT is a 4th impression and seems definitely shorter than the other two.
13 Aug, 2023
2023-8-13 10:36:34 AM UTC

Max wrote:

I'm not sure it applies only to FOTR, look at this link:

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated
Seller: junescollectables
(2643)
Ended Aug 22, 2023
This item ended more than 90 days ago


TTT is a 4th impression and seems definitely shorter than the other two.

Looking at the image with all the books standing upright with the spines facing out, it looks like the surface is not level and the Two Towers is standing lower in a dip.
13 Aug, 2023
2023-8-13 12:01:01 PM UTC
LanceFormation : you're definitely right.
Picture 4 of this listing shows the 3 books having the same height. I never heard about a shorter UK two towers impression.
13 Aug, 2023
2023-8-13 1:18:21 PM UTC
Thanks guys, so the problem affects only specific impressions of FOTR. I should get the all 1sts to solve the issue.
13 Aug, 2023
2023-8-13 2:02:15 PM UTC

Max wrote:

Thanks guys, so the problem affects only specific impressions of FOTR. I should get the all 1sts to solve the issue.

Ha, yes! Getting them all is the best way 😀

And one of our members (Berelach) put this handy guide together on printers, binding size, etc., for UK 1st edition FOTRs:

5090_64d8e22994253.jpeg 1290X1354 px
13 Aug, 2023
2023-8-13 2:37:01 PM UTC
Wow, really nice guide, does it exists also for TTT and ROTK?

Many thanks
13 Aug, 2023 (edited)
2023-8-13 3:13:43 PM UTC
I think this was put together to assist in documenting mainly the size difference seen within FOTR impressions. Not really needed for TT and ROTK.

But, if you are interested in some overall printing and binding history for the UK first edition, check out this:

https://tolkienbooks.net/php/lotr-print-runs.php



14 Aug, 2023
2023-8-14 7:40:16 AM UTC
My 753 set is basically my pride and joy…

I actually love the shorter fellowship. It’s a bit chonkier. Nice shape to it.

5660_64d9da6031b2f.jpeg 1536X2048 px
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us