TolkienGuide.com
Powered by Collectors Since 2006
Sign In
TolkienGuide.com
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
(Nominated for 2026 Tolkien Society Award)
-
Guide to Tolkien Calendars
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

12

Options for Illustrated editions (Alan Lee, etc) of Hobbit and Lord of the Rings

7 Jul, 2025
2025-7-7 11:03:07 PM UTC

Hi all. Compared to many of you, I have a pretty minimalist collection. However, I'm interested in getting the Alan Lee illustrated versions of the Hobbit and LOTR.

I don't have any official illustrated versions, so one of my main objectives is to obtain copies of Alan Lee's illustrations. I do think the 2024 Deluxe editions have a few extra illustrations, but overall are quite comparable to the 2020 HC (and presumably 2025 WM) books. I want something that is good quality, especially in the sense of being readable. In other words, quality of printed text and images and quality of binding are the biggest priorities. I don't particularly care about matte vs glossy paper for images, though I might prefer matte for text. More important for images are the brightness, color, and ink quality. Regarding binding quality, I would want something durable and also something that doesn't tend to open in "clumps." I would love to have copies that are not bound too tight (i.e. able to read while holding in the hand, not on a table or desk, and without having to force open the book). Regarding text, I would prefer to have the newest reset text and updated index, mainly for the Lord of the Rings. Does anyone know if the 2020 HC version (below) has the same updated text as the 70th anniversary? Or is it still using the older ~2005 update?

Here are the options that I'm seeing for Alan Lee editions of the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings. (these are all available or will be available as of mid-to-late 2025)
1) 2020 HarperCollins Hobbit and LOTR boxed set (ISBN 9780008376109)
Did this one have some bad printings? If so, what is my chance of getting a bad set ordering direct from Amazon? (i.e. not from a 3rd party seller) I've seen it discussed somewhere, but how many illustrations would I be missing with this over the 70th anniversary versions below? I realize it may be too early to know what extra images are in the Hobbit versions.
2) 2025 William Morrow Hobbit and LOTR boxed set (ISBN 9780063451964)
Do new/1st printings tend to be higher quality or more collectable? If I get this in a few months, would it likely be better quality than a recent printing of the 2020 set, above?
3) 2024 HC 70th Anniversary LOTR + 2025 HC Hobbit (ISBN 9780008669430 + ISBN 9780008779900)
4) 2024 WM 70th Anniversary LOTR + 2025 WM Hobbit (ISBN 9780063392939 + ISBN 9780063473423)
For both 3 & 4, the HC and WM LOTR copies, what has your experience been regarding printing/image/binding quality? What impressions are currently being shipped from vendors, and do you think the added cost equates to better quality when comparing 3&4 to 1&2?
5) 1997 WM Hobbit + 2002 WM LOTR (ISBN 9780395873465 + ISBN 9780618260515 + ISBN 9780618260591 + ISBN 9780618260553)
For these versions, how many Alan Lee illustrations would I be missing? It looks like they're still being printed or maybe the available books are just extra inventory... but how has the quality been on these versions? I realize these have the older text version, but how was print/binding quality?

As a side note, the 40th anniversary deluxe Unfinished Tales (2020, ISBN 9780008387969) and 2021 Deluxe Silmarillion (ISBN 9780008433956) also look quite nice to me. Would they go well in terms of size with the 2024 Deluxe LOTR?

For those of you that have some or all of these, I'd love to hear some comparisons, likes, and dislikes. I realize I'm asking for some speculation and conjecture, but the collective wisdom and experience on here could easily point me in the right direction. Thanks for any suggestions. Beginning a collection is a slippery slope!
8 Jul, 2025
2025-7-8 12:33:33 AM UTC
The deluxe Unfinished Tales and Silmarillion you mentioned (the clothbound ones) are among my favorite Tolkien books, along with Robert Foster's "Complete Guide to Middle-earth" in the same style. I just love the look of them. They also hold up quite well to readings for a deluxe edition, if you don't mind a little fading of the board corners.

Wish they'd have made more releases in this series.
8 Jul, 2025
2025-7-8 1:01:19 AM UTC
From what you are saying either the 2020 box set or the 2024 LotR + 2025 Hobbit seem to be the best choice for you.

I own all of the editions you mentioned (except the ones that have not been released yet) and to me the 1997 WM Hobbit and 2002 WM LotR are the highest quality and most beautiful versions. These are NOT for reading while holding them in your hand though as they're very large and heavy. Also, the text is on glossy pages.

The readability is about the same between the HC 2020 box set and the HC 70th LotR I would say, even though some have been complaining that the binding on the latter is a bit too tight. They both have the same text but the reproduction of the paintings is different. You can get a good impression here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/tolkienbooks/ ... 0_%C3%A9dition_comparing/
You'll also have to make up your mind on whether you like the new decorative boxes around the images in the 70th. Here's what's new about the art in this edition:
https://www.reddit.com/r/tolkienbooks/ ... on_new_art_from_alan_lee/

I think that the 70th are the "nicer" books overall. Size-wise they're the same. Both match the size of the 2020 UT and 2021 Silmarillion you mentioned. I agree that those are very nice books. That Silmarillion has terrible shelf-appeal though, as the contrast of the gilt on orange is very low. (It's so bad I decided to turn it around and display the back of the [beautiful] slipcase instead.)
There are exactly matching versions of UT (9780008387952) and S (9780008433949) (and many more) for the 2020 box set.

1st impressions are generally more collectable and usually good quality, in some cases better than later impressions. For the 70th the HC and WM versions are exactly the same (printed in Italy by Graphicom) except the publisher logos. I own 8th impressions of the 2020 box set and these are very good quality (printed in Italy by Rotolito), same as the matching 5th imp Silmarillion and 4th UT.

If you are planning to get matching UT and S:
- There might never be a UT to exactly match the 70th, because this and the hobbit are made in the likeness of the recent larger Folio Society limited editions and as far as I know FS has only ever made Hobbits LotRs and Silmarillions.
- If you want to get the above mentioned UT to match the 2020 box set avoid 1st/2nd (missing "J.R.R. Tolkien" on the spine) and 5th (terrible quality binding from Dubai) impressions.

All in all I think the 70th LotR and 2025 Hobbit along with the 2020 UT and 2021 Silmarillion (or an eventual matching Silmarillion) would make the nicer collection, while the 2020 box set along with the other matching books offers almost comparable readability at a much lower price.
8 Jul, 2025
2025-7-8 10:39:29 PM UTC
Personally, I'm interested in the Alan Lee sets.

There seems to be a hardcover edition in dust jackets from 2020 that includes The Hobbit and the LotR, but oddly I see a pre-order on Amazon for what appears to be the exact same set. I'm wondering if these (at least in their 2020 incarnation) have sewn bindings. That's really an important criteria for me.

I'm also looking at the deluxe edition, which is even more appealing given that (a) the price on Amazon has come down a bit and (b) they've now announced a matching edition of The Hobbit.

I fear the answer will be, get both the deluxe edition and one or another of the versions of the standard four-volume edition in dust jackets...because "collector."

8 Jul, 2025
2025-7-8 11:12:32 PM UTC
There's a forum here
discussing the upcoming (2025) release you're referencing. In short, it's a William Morrow release of the exact same Harper Collins set from 2020.

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated

The Hobbit & The Lord of the Rings Illustrated by Alan Lee Box Set: (US, HB)

Tolkien, J. R. R.
9780063451964
William Morrow (2025-10-14)

$139.80 Bookshop.org (USA Only) - Availability: Click to check
$78.26 Amazon.com (Hardcover) - Availability: LEADTIME
£96.95 Amazon.co.uk (Hardcover) - Availability: LEADTIME
€130.38 Amazon.de (Gebundene Ausgabe) - Availability: LEADTIME
$100.00 AbeBooks - Availability: Click to check
$75.00 eBay US - Availability: Click to check
£75.00 eBay UK - Availability: Click to check


My impression is that the William Morrow and Harper Collins sets are considered equivalent. I suspect many collectors prefer to stay with one publisher even if just because of the homogeneity on the shelf. My impression is also that both editions are sewn binding, but I don't have a physical copy to check. Also, within HC and WM, there will clearly be some quality variation with each impression or printing. But yes, true collectors will probably end up with all of them!

ESS & rosshm16 Thanks for the feedback! I will be on the lookout for discounts on the 2024 Deluxe LOTR + 2025 Deluxe Hobbit. I'll probably go WM here in the US but we shall see. Also looking into those 2021 Deluxe S and UT. I love the look, even the gold on orange! (Yes, I'm weird.) How low have you seen prices? Is the $90 on Amazon US a decent price?

Thanks.
8 Jul, 2025
2025-7-8 11:36:43 PM UTC
I think $90 is pretty good, on the lower end of the usual range for those books.

Someone asked about bindings: I don't have many of them, so going off hearsay here, but recent non-"deluxe" hardcover editions from HC/WM generally have glued bindings.
9 Jul, 2025
2025-7-9 6:20:12 AM UTC

wiseSam wrote:


I'll probably go WM here in the US but we shall see. Also looking into those 2021 Deluxe S and UT. I love the look, even the gold on orange! (Yes, I'm weird.) How low have you seen prices? Is the $90 on Amazon US a decent price?

I love the look of the orange Silmarillion, too. It's in an by itself a very beautiful (and readable) book that I cherish, so don't hold back on it ($90 is decent). What I meant to give you a heads-up about is that due to said low contrast the spine is going to appear heavily worn from the start when you put it next to other books – even the UT of the same edition.
10 Jul, 2025
2025-7-10 6:37:04 PM UTC
Thanks!
18 Jul, 2025 (edited)
2025-7-18 10:46:45 PM UTC
I'll post some pictures and details later, but I just received the 2024 Deluxe LOTR (2nd printing, Graphicom, only complaint is mild blurring of the printing on The Two Towers spine. Otherwise they're perfect and I'm happy that binding is not too tight) and now have the 2020-2021 Deluxe Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales.

Mainly because of ESS , I also got a hodge podge set of the larger 2002 LOTR illustrated sets and the corresponding Hobbit and Silmarllion.

One question: Regarding the text version of the 2024 Deluxe LOTR, it says it's based on the 2020 Illustrated set. Can someone post a picture of the copyright page from the front of their Fellowship of the Ring book from that set? I was hoping it would be more helpful in its description. (HarperCollins Hobbit and LOTR boxed set - ISBN 9780008376109)

Thanks. I'll post pics/details for some of the purchases.
19 Jul, 2025
2025-7-19 10:31:43 AM UTC

wiseSam wrote:

Mainly because of ESS , I also got a hodge podge set of the larger 2002 LOTR illustrated sets and the corresponding Hobbit and Silmarllion.

One question: Regarding the text version of the 2024 Deluxe LOTR, it says it's based on the 2020 Illustrated set. Can someone post a picture of the copyright page from the front of their Fellowship of the Ring book from that set? I was hoping it would be more helpful in its description. (HarperCollins Hobbit and LOTR boxed set - ISBN 9780008376109)

Congrats on your new acquisitions!

Here's a picture of said copyright page. I think the answer you seek can be found in this article by Findegil : https://wayneandchristina.wordpress.co ... f-the-rings-comparison-4/


5735_687b73f434346.jpg 1571X2775 px
12
Jump to Last
All original content © by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us