TolkienGuide.com
Powered by Collectors Since 2006
Sign In
TolkienGuide.com
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
(Nominated for 2026 Tolkien Society Award)
-
Guide to Tolkien Calendars
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

The Hobbit first edition bought for £1.50 could fetch thousands

31 Jan, 2024 (edited)
2024-1-31 8:19:25 PM UTC

Grima: Noble Two Towers expansion 2003, Eaglemoss Two Towers 2007, Hauser 1978, Jackson Trilogy 2004



A first edition of The Hobbit bought at a car boot sale for £1.50 could be worth thousands of pounds if sold at auction.

The text was among a box of random books a bargain hunter picked up at Bath Racecourse - after he knocked the seller down from £2.

He then plonked them in his garage to gather dust for the next five years.

On putting up a shelf he remembered the books and rescued them from the outbuilding.

After setting aside a book on medicine, one among the others caught his eye.

Bargain Hunt star Richard Madley, from Cardiff, dubbed the text "one of the holy grails".

"He glanced upon a bright green, white and blue jacket and thought, 'That's quite jazzy, it looks 1930s to me'," Mr Madley explained.

"He looked at the cover and thought, 'Oh, The Hobbit by JRR Tolkien.'

"He put it down, made a cup of coffee and got on the internet. And thought, 'Holy shamoley'.

"The next morning he knocked on my door."

Bargain Hunt star Richard Madley said only a few thousand were ever printed

The book was a 1937 first edition, second impression copy of Tolkien's children's fantasy novel.

Mr Madley said only a few thousand were published but the printer was bombed in the Blitz so even fewer survived.

Last year one sold at auction for more than £10,000 after being found among donations to an Oxfam shop.

Mr Madley called up a specialist book auctioneer friend for an estimate.

He asked if it had been "price clipped".

Sometimes book buyers snip the price from the slip cover to hide how much it was bought for.

The 7/6d price was still there, Mr Madley replied.

Mr Madley told BBC Radio Wales Behnaz Akghar: "He said, 'I would put an estimate of between £6,000 and £8,000 on it, that is my guide price'. He said, 'How much did it cost?'

"I said, '£1.50'. He said, 'You're joking'."

On assuring him it was not a joke, Mr Madley was told: "If it came on the open market it could exceed even the high estimate and push on to nearly five figures."

It's unclear whether the book will be sold or whether the owner will keep it, perhaps to leave it in his will to his children.

"Some will say it's better than money in the bank, in which case the owner of this book may decide that he might put it away for 10 years and bring it back on the market then," Mr Madley said.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-68145612



Very low estimate with a dust-jacket. From listening to the clip, the estimate is from Rupert Powell of Forum Auctions, if the seller does decide to sell then it could end up being sold through them.
Gallery

10_65baab0712e94.webp 976X549 px
1 Feb, 2024
2024-2-1 8:35:27 AM UTC
I wonder if the seller had looked at the books they had for sale for £2, and had never heard of Tolkien or The Hobbit. 🤦
1 Feb, 2024
2024-2-1 6:10:20 PM UTC

Trotter wrote:

I wonder if the seller had looked at the books they had for sale for £2, and had never heard of Tolkien or The Hobbit. 🤦

Maybe so. Also in my experience many times at these used book sales (or similar - yard/garage sales, etc), most folks simply have no awareness that old books may have additional value on the secondary market or even be of interest. I've had sweet old ladies at book sales give me an extra 20 books for free when I asked about no price label being on the books simply because I was already buying so many other books.

Even professional estate sale staff, who in theory should know better, aren't much more aware of the book market. A few months ago I went to an estate sale of a very minor political celebrity (now deceased) whom the general public would not have known but was very well connected in national American politics (among items being sold were personally signed correspondence from the Clintons, personal invitations to Nixon's inauguration etc). As I walk into the house, the estate sale manager is shouting "All books are now free, take what you want!" I picked up about 50 books for free, including several signed and inscribed by notable authors (nothing from Tolkien unfortunately). And I would have grabbed another 30 or so if my wife hadn't been staring me down in a very threatening manner...
1 Feb, 2024
2024-2-1 6:17:08 PM UTC
I know this sort of thing happens, have a look at this post from 13 years ago

https://www.tolkienguide.com/modules/n ... ost_id=8686#forumpost8686
1 Feb, 2024
2024-2-1 6:33:14 PM UTC

Trotter wrote:

I know this sort of thing happens, have a look at this post from 13 years ago

https://www.tolkienguide.com/modules/n ... ost_id=8686#forumpost8686

Amazing find by your uncle and several other great stories in that thread! This is why I need to move to the U.K., far better chance of happening upon some Tolkien signatures there than on this side of the Atlantic.
Jump to Last
All original content © by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us