9 Dec, 2024
(edited)
2024-12-9 11:08:45 PM UTC
Edited by Taivo on 2024-12-9 11:19:03 PM UTC
Edited by Taivo on 2024-12-9 11:24:24 PM UTC
Edited by Taivo on 2024-12-10 2:09:25 PM UTC
Edited by Taivo on 2024-12-9 11:24:24 PM UTC
Edited by Taivo on 2024-12-10 2:09:25 PM UTC
2024-12-9 11:08:45 PM UTC
After zionius pointed out that I was missing two editions from the "2024 Chinese Collection", I was able to find them and add them to my collection. Here they are.

(ISBN for all three: 978-7-5541-7313-8)
Tolkien, J.R.R. 魔戒. Translated by Guowei Liu. Vol. 1, 魔戒同盟. Xi’an Publishing House, 2024.
———. 魔戒. Translated by Nana Shan. Vol. 2, 双塔殊途. Xi’an Publishing House, 2024.
———. 魔戒. Translated by Nana Shan. Vol. 3, 王者归来. Xi’an Publishing House, 2024.

(ISBN for all three: 978-7-5762-4428-1)
Tolkien, J.R.R. 魔戒. Translated by Fei Long. Vol. 1, 护戒使者. Jiangxi University Press, 2024.
———. 魔戒. Translated by Fei Long. Vol. 2, 双塔奇兵. Jiangxi University Press, 2024.
———. 魔戒. Translated by Fei Long. Vol. 3, 王者归来. Jiangxi University Press, 2024.
(The covers on this set include colored foil inlays of a ring in the center of the main image and the title below. My scanner does not pick up colored foils well, but you can see hints of what they look like in the center volume. The colors are yellow, red, and green.

(ISBN for all three: 978-7-5541-7313-8)
Tolkien, J.R.R. 魔戒. Translated by Guowei Liu. Vol. 1, 魔戒同盟. Xi’an Publishing House, 2024.
———. 魔戒. Translated by Nana Shan. Vol. 2, 双塔殊途. Xi’an Publishing House, 2024.
———. 魔戒. Translated by Nana Shan. Vol. 3, 王者归来. Xi’an Publishing House, 2024.

(ISBN for all three: 978-7-5762-4428-1)
Tolkien, J.R.R. 魔戒. Translated by Fei Long. Vol. 1, 护戒使者. Jiangxi University Press, 2024.
———. 魔戒. Translated by Fei Long. Vol. 2, 双塔奇兵. Jiangxi University Press, 2024.
———. 魔戒. Translated by Fei Long. Vol. 3, 王者归来. Jiangxi University Press, 2024.
(The covers on this set include colored foil inlays of a ring in the center of the main image and the title below. My scanner does not pick up colored foils well, but you can see hints of what they look like in the center volume. The colors are yellow, red, and green.
zionius. I just bought a copy of the 2025 Chen Sen Popular Science Press "translation". I'm not sure whether this is a new "simplified translation" for younger readers or a simplification of a previous translation. (My Chinese is via Google Translate, of course). In comparing the first paragraph of Fellowship to other translations, it looks to be much simpler in structure and the comment about the rumors of how Bilbo acquired his wealth has been turned into a direct quote. Can you clarify a bit for me what the nature and history of this "translation" is? Thank you.
19 February
(edited)
2026-2-19 2:18:13 PM UTC
Edited by zionius on 2026-2-19 2:19:33 PM UTC
Edited by zionius on 2026-2-19 2:30:12 PM UTC
Edited by zionius on 2026-2-19 2:31:46 PM UTC
Edited by zionius on 2026-2-19 2:32:43 PM UTC
Edited by zionius on 2026-2-19 2:30:12 PM UTC
Edited by zionius on 2026-2-19 2:31:46 PM UTC
Edited by zionius on 2026-2-19 2:32:43 PM UTC
2026-2-19 2:18:13 PM UTC
This is a heavily abridged translation , as can be easily seen from the length. The blurb says "This edition is a young readers' adaptation of the novel. While preserving the essence of the original, it has been carefully adapted for readers aged 8 to 18." Chen Sen is credited as "Translated and edited by" or "Compiled by"(编译).
Most new translations published since 2024 are craps, and some are actually "adopted" from earlier Chinese ones (ie. content spinning). It is hard to say whether this one is the case without careful comparisons; the sample pages appear to suggest it is original.
This is the third abridged Chinese version of LR. The second one is 9787545586268 which you already own. The first one is in a collection of children’s literature published in 1992 (7535807178), potting LR in 20 pages. It also contains abridged Hobbit in 7 pages, and two interesting reviews. See https://weibo.com/5760963846/O7Yf3oi0D and https://weibo.com/5760963846/O82aAz8Cn for the contents. If you want the book, you can find it in https://search.kongfz.com/product/?keyword=7535807178 (note some are not first printings)
Most new translations published since 2024 are craps, and some are actually "adopted" from earlier Chinese ones (ie. content spinning). It is hard to say whether this one is the case without careful comparisons; the sample pages appear to suggest it is original.
This is the third abridged Chinese version of LR. The second one is 9787545586268 which you already own. The first one is in a collection of children’s literature published in 1992 (7535807178), potting LR in 20 pages. It also contains abridged Hobbit in 7 pages, and two interesting reviews. See https://weibo.com/5760963846/O7Yf3oi0D and https://weibo.com/5760963846/O82aAz8Cn for the contents. If you want the book, you can find it in https://search.kongfz.com/product/?keyword=7535807178 (note some are not first printings)
zionius. Thanks! I suspected as much, but I knew you would have a much more accurate assessment. I'm glad you mentioned 9787545586268. I bought that back when new Chinese translations were falling like rain and didn't notice that it was also an abridgement. I'll be sure to mark it as such.
Same one jumped out to me!Erithamrod wrote:
The third one looks gorgeous! Do you know which artist drew the cover images?
Luckyshot wrote:
Same one jumped out to me!Erithamrod wrote:
The third one looks gorgeous! Do you know which artist drew the cover images?
That one is nice.
There's also a new one published in 2025 that has some pretty stunning art (ISBN: 978-7-5455-8626-8):

3 new editions hit the market: 9787573161222, 9787575310710, 9787513952354(a full color children's book)
https://detail.tmall.com/item.htm?abbu ... 83423&skuId=6048128097577
The last one has an ISBN of 9787545586268 (but seems to be the one referred to above? - 9787513952354)
https://detail.tmall.com/item.htm?ali_ ... c9d8ad73%22%7D&xxc=ad_ztc
The last one has an ISBN of 9787545586268 (but seems to be the one referred to above? - 9787513952354)
https://detail.tmall.com/item.htm?ali_ ... c9d8ad73%22%7D&xxc=ad_ztc
16 April
(edited)
2026-4-16 12:28:58 AM UTC
Edited by remy on 2026-4-16 12:29:23 AM UTC
Edited by remy on 2026-4-16 12:30:33 AM UTC
Edited by Urulókë on 2026-4-16 12:30:44 AM UTC
Edited by remy on 2026-4-16 12:30:33 AM UTC
Edited by Urulókë on 2026-4-16 12:30:44 AM UTC
2026-4-16 12:28:58 AM UTC
https://detail.tmall.com/item.htm?abbu ... 83423&skuId=6048128097577
This one seems like it may be a nice quality production...... Clothbound and Interesting Slipcase.....
This one seems like it may be a nice quality production...... Clothbound and Interesting Slipcase.....




.jpeg)
0