18 Nov, 2025
(edited)
2025-11-18 5:51:54 AM UTC
Edited by The late Stu on 2025-11-18 5:52:33 AM UTC
Edited by Trotter on 2025-11-18 6:26:48 AM UTC
Edited by Trotter on 2025-11-18 6:26:48 AM UTC
2025-11-18 5:51:54 AM UTC
Jlong wrote:
What happened here?
Link to absurdly high priced / slightly predatory (IMHO) listing for a Wheelbarrows at Dawn (additional copies seem to keep on cropping up at ever higher prices from the original publisher) was taken down, I think. This one was £12,000 or more, IIRC. I facepalmed when I saw it.
The late Stu wrote:
Jlong wrote:
What happened here?
Link to absurdly high priced / slightly predatory (IMHO) listing for a Wheelbarrows at Dawn (additional copies seem to keep on cropping up at ever higher prices from the original publisher) was taken down, I think. This one was £12,000 or more, IIRC. I facepalmed when I saw it.
Yup as Stu says, stupid asking price from a seller who has a history of dishonest listing practices and predatory pricing. Some just can't take a bit of criticism I guess.
The late Stu wrote:
Jlong wrote:
What happened here?
Link to absurdly high priced / slightly predatory (IMHO) listing for a Wheelbarrows at Dawn (additional copies seem to keep on cropping up at ever higher prices from the original publisher) was taken down, I think. This one was £12,000 or more, IIRC. I facepalmed when I saw it.
I concur--that belongs in wonders, not here.
J. R. R. Tolkien. Autograph manuscript, headed "Further correction desired," being a late revision to The Return of the King, Book Six, Chapter VI ("Many Partings"). N.p. [Spring 1955].
[LINK]
Starting Bid: $15,000
Reserve (if any) Not Posted Yet
"The sheet is annotated at upper right in another hand in blue ink: "p 256/ line / 25" [this actually occurs at line 26]; and in another hand in red ink on the lower half of the page beside a red check mark: in red ink "Corrected / J[not legible] / 11-6-55." The "J" may stand for Jarrold & Sons, the printers.
"The fragment contains revisions for text in the third volume of The Lord of the Rings trilogy. It is a correction to the text which appears on page 256, line 26 of the first edition of The Return of the King. In Christopher Tolkien's Sauron Defeated he mentions that this correction "entered on the galley Proof" (p. 68). The specific passage concerned is the change from "and in the deeps of time it was made for our forefathers by the dwarves" to "It was made by the Dwarves, and came from the hoard of Scatha the Worm."
"In a letter from Charles B. Elston, archivist at Marquette University, responding to the consignor of the present lot, he writes: "I have reviewed our manuscript holdings for the text in question contained in Chapter VI, "Many Partings," of Book Six of The Lord of the Rings. The correction, as mentioned by Christopher Tolkien, appears only on the galley sheets for Book Six. Both a holograph manuscript and typescript manuscript of "Many Partings" contain only the early version of the text ("and in the deeps of time it was made for our forefathers by the dwarves")."
[LINK]
Starting Bid: $15,000
Reserve (if any) Not Posted Yet
"The sheet is annotated at upper right in another hand in blue ink: "p 256/ line / 25" [this actually occurs at line 26]; and in another hand in red ink on the lower half of the page beside a red check mark: in red ink "Corrected / J[not legible] / 11-6-55." The "J" may stand for Jarrold & Sons, the printers.
"The fragment contains revisions for text in the third volume of The Lord of the Rings trilogy. It is a correction to the text which appears on page 256, line 26 of the first edition of The Return of the King. In Christopher Tolkien's Sauron Defeated he mentions that this correction "entered on the galley Proof" (p. 68). The specific passage concerned is the change from "and in the deeps of time it was made for our forefathers by the dwarves" to "It was made by the Dwarves, and came from the hoard of Scatha the Worm."
"In a letter from Charles B. Elston, archivist at Marquette University, responding to the consignor of the present lot, he writes: "I have reviewed our manuscript holdings for the text in question contained in Chapter VI, "Many Partings," of Book Six of The Lord of the Rings. The correction, as mentioned by Christopher Tolkien, appears only on the galley sheets for Book Six. Both a holograph manuscript and typescript manuscript of "Many Partings" contain only the early version of the text ("and in the deeps of time it was made for our forefathers by the dwarves")."

[J. R. R. Tolkien]. 2 Tolkien references. Includes:
Christina Scull and Wayne G. Hammond. The Tolkien Collector Archive. London and Boston: Privately Published, 1992- 2002.
Includes:
1) 26 paper folded, stapled volumes of "The Tolkien Collector"
2) Paper folded, stapled "Index [volumes] 1-20"
3) 13 page paper stapled "Catalogue of Books and Ephemera Chiefly Concerning J. R. R. Tolkien from the Collections of Wayne G. Hammond & Christina Scull
4) Single sheet "Interim Number"
5) Printed pamphlet for "Tolkien Times, Autumn 1998."
Starting Bid: $1
No Reserve
[LINK]
Christina Scull and Wayne G. Hammond. The Tolkien Collector Archive. London and Boston: Privately Published, 1992- 2002.
Includes:
1) 26 paper folded, stapled volumes of "The Tolkien Collector"
2) Paper folded, stapled "Index [volumes] 1-20"
3) 13 page paper stapled "Catalogue of Books and Ephemera Chiefly Concerning J. R. R. Tolkien from the Collections of Wayne G. Hammond & Christina Scull
4) Single sheet "Interim Number"
5) Printed pamphlet for "Tolkien Times, Autumn 1998."
Starting Bid: $1
No Reserve
[LINK]

18 Nov, 2025
(edited)
2025-11-18 4:58:07 PM UTC
Edited by Aelfwine on 2025-11-18 5:00:52 PM UTC
Edited by Urulókë on 2025-11-18 5:10:52 PM UTC
Edited by Urulókë on 2025-11-18 5:10:52 PM UTC
2025-11-18 4:58:07 PM UTC
J. R. R. Tolkien. The Silmarillion. Edited by Christopher Tolkien. [London]: Harper Collins, [1998].
8vo. Illustrated with 18 color plates by Ted Nasmith. Publisher's quarter leather and russet cloth, upper cover and spine stamped in gilt, color pictorial endpapers showing the map of Beleriand and the Lands to the North, edges gilt; original matching russet cloth slipcase with the Tolkien monogram stamped in gilt on one side.
FIRST ILLUSTRATED EDITION, LIMITED ISSUE, number 177 of 500 specially bound and slipcased copies signed by editor, Christopher Tolkien, and illustrator, Ted Nasmith.
Starting Bid: $500
Reserve (if any) Not Posted Yet
[LINK]
8vo. Illustrated with 18 color plates by Ted Nasmith. Publisher's quarter leather and russet cloth, upper cover and spine stamped in gilt, color pictorial endpapers showing the map of Beleriand and the Lands to the North, edges gilt; original matching russet cloth slipcase with the Tolkien monogram stamped in gilt on one side.
FIRST ILLUSTRATED EDITION, LIMITED ISSUE, number 177 of 500 specially bound and slipcased copies signed by editor, Christopher Tolkien, and illustrator, Ted Nasmith.
Starting Bid: $500
Reserve (if any) Not Posted Yet
[LINK]

J. R. R. Tolkien. The Lord of the Rings: comprising The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, and The Return of the King. London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1954-1955.
3 volumes, 8vo. In-text illustration by Tolkien in Fellowship ("The Doors of Durin"); folding map by the author's son, Christopher Tolkien, tipped-in at rear of each volume. Publisher's red cloth, spines stamped in gilt, top edges red; original illustrated dust jackets. Housed together in a custom quarter morocco slipcase, decorated in gilt, spines with onlaid "Ring and Eye" designs, and one, two, or three rings, by R. Patron, Hollywood CA.
A SUPERLATIVE SET IN VERY FINE UNRESTORED CONDITION.
FIRST EDITIONS, FIRST IMPRESSIONS.
Starting Bid: $50,000
Reserve (if any) Not Posted Yet
[LINK]
3 volumes, 8vo. In-text illustration by Tolkien in Fellowship ("The Doors of Durin"); folding map by the author's son, Christopher Tolkien, tipped-in at rear of each volume. Publisher's red cloth, spines stamped in gilt, top edges red; original illustrated dust jackets. Housed together in a custom quarter morocco slipcase, decorated in gilt, spines with onlaid "Ring and Eye" designs, and one, two, or three rings, by R. Patron, Hollywood CA.
A SUPERLATIVE SET IN VERY FINE UNRESTORED CONDITION.
FIRST EDITIONS, FIRST IMPRESSIONS.
Starting Bid: $50,000
Reserve (if any) Not Posted Yet
[LINK]

J. R. R. Tolkien. Autograph manuscript, headed "Further correction desired," being a late revision to The Return of the King, Book Six, Chapter VI ("Many Partings"). N.p. [Spring 1955].
...
In Christopher Tolkien's Sauron Defeated he mentions that this correction "entered on the galley Proof" (p. 68). The specific passage concerned is the change from "and in the deeps of time it was made for our forefathers by the dwarves" to "It was made by the Dwarves, and came from the hoard of Scatha the Worm."
In the Collected Poems it is said that this edit happened "around 1954" in a "manuscript note", which surprised me, given the 1955 release date and all the messing around with the Appendices. I guess "around 1954" might be the best guess at a relatively undated jotting, and then Tolkien wrote the note here for sale in 1955. And then worked on the Scatha poem (which link sparked my curiosity to look up the chronology here) after correcting the sentence in proof, according to Scull and Hammond.
I sent a note to a Tolkien Gateway person that the page for the poem lists it as "around 1954", which can't be correct if the sequencing and dates for the edits introducing Scatha are all valid.




.jpeg)
5433