TolkienGuide.com
Powered by Collectors Since 2006
Sign In
TolkienGuide.com
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
(Nominated for 2026 Tolkien Society Award)
-
Guide to Tolkien Calendars
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...345
15 Dec, 2025
2025-12-15 2:51:20 PM UTC
Dawn was as good as her word and my replacement copy arrived today. Very happy :)
22 Dec, 2025
2025-12-22 10:51:01 PM UTC
I just received my copy today of the WM US printing, and unfortunately it is the 1st edition.
Does anyone know if there has been a second printing from WM as of yet? Has anyone successfully contact their customer support about a replacement (seems like everyone in this thread got the HC version)?
21 March
2026-3-21 5:37:17 PM UTC
i noticed on amazon USA there is a kindle version available, but none available on amazon UK. Does anyone know if we will get the kindle edition over here ?
21 March
2026-3-21 5:59:14 PM UTC

Gerontius Took wrote:

i noticed on amazon USA there is a kindle version available, but none available on amazon UK. Does anyone know if we will get the kindle edition over here ?

Does not look like it is a Kindle version, as it is available on other e-readers such as the Kobo.

https://www.kobo.com/us/en/ebook/the-h ... z8uWh8mC3KdD-C2t7P&cPos=1
21 March
2026-3-21 6:55:57 PM UTC

Trotter wrote:

Gerontius Took wrote:

i noticed on amazon USA there is a kindle version available, but none available on amazon UK. Does anyone know if we will get the kindle edition over here ?

Does not look like it is a Kindle version, as it is available on other e-readers such as the Kobo.

https://www.kobo.com/us/en/ebook/the-h ... z8uWh8mC3KdD-C2t7P&cPos=1

Ah ok thanks Trotter. It is listed as the kindle though
23 March (edited)
2026-3-23 3:06:39 AM UTC
Wow I didn't realize there were missing pages! I ordered the William Morrow version when it first came out, so I am way outside of the return policy. Is anyone aware of a contact for problems with William Morrow printings? In the past, I've reached out to The Harper Collins customer service (multiple times) and received no response whatsoever.

Also, has anyone heard of a corrected second print yet for William Morrow?
23 March
2026-3-23 2:55:37 PM UTC

Fatty Lumpkin's Saddle wrote:

Wow I didn't realize there were missing pages! I ordered the William Morrow version when it first came out, so I am way outside of the return policy. Is anyone aware of a contact for problems with William Morrow printings? In the past, I've reached out to The Harper Collins customer service (multiple times) and received no response whatsoever.

Also, has anyone heard of a corrected second print yet for William Morrow?

My experience dealing with WM customer service on this issue was frustrating. I did actually get a response, but the representative I talked to didn't really seem to be aware of the known issue. I asked for a replacement, but only if there was a corrected printing available. Then when they did send a new book, it ended up being just the older softcover edition. So, I still don't have a corrected hard cover of the revised edition.
1 May
2026-5-1 6:19:15 AM UTC
I recently bought the Graphic Novel. It's my first edition and I really think it's a wonderful adaptation. Annoying that these mistakes happened, but I guess that's what it is.

Anyway, I am happy to report, as of the third printing (my copy), all mistakes have been fixed, even the redundant text box on page 128. At least with the Harper Collins version. I got mine from Amazon, so if anyone was still holding off, I think it's safe to say you can go for it now.
6 May
2026-5-6 10:30:57 PM UTC

fgdj2000 wrote:

I recently bought the Graphic Novel. It's my first edition and I really think it's a wonderful adaptation. Annoying that these mistakes happened, but I guess that's what it is.

Anyway, I am happy to report, as of the third printing (my copy), all mistakes have been fixed, even the redundant text box on page 128. At least with the Harper Collins version. I got mine from Amazon, so if anyone was still holding off, I think it's safe to say you can go for it now.

Great news! Will order as soon as possible!
25 May
2026-5-25 3:42:18 AM UTC
I am curious if anyone has recently ordered from Blackwell’s and received the corrected version of the graphic novel - drop a note if you have!
1...345
Jump to Last
All original content © by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us