Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

12345...15
30 Apr, 2020
2020-4-30 12:14:36 AM UTC

insurrbution wrote:
There is that, though you might risk it being reprinted, and not get a first printing - if that's a factor.

You, best not to wait too long. The price usually drops a few days after release. They get all the pre-orders at a higher price, then drop it to get the stragglers. I never bother pre-ordering and I have never ended up with a reprint.
30 Apr, 2020
2020-4-30 8:39:52 PM UTC
Not sure how Book Depository pricing is in the UK, but that was really the only current option to get it in NZ (was about £58 delivered, which could be worse given prices now include 15% NZ GST and airfreight is super-super expensive). Owned by Amazon, of course.
1 May, 2020
2020-5-1 1:28:43 AM UTC
I paid about the sane to get it to Australia due to the 10% GST. Ugh!
1 May, 2020
2020-5-1 6:46:04 PM UTC
Has anyone received their copies yet? Wasn't anticipating getting mine anytime soon (Amazon.co.uk isn't shipping to the US at the moment -- which is completely understandable). So I made an order with Book Depository a week or 2 back and just got a shipping notification today.
1 May, 2020
2020-5-1 6:52:09 PM UTC
My copy shipped this morning too; hope to have in hand early next week.
4 May, 2020
2020-5-4 7:24:06 AM UTC
Speaking about the "bonus content", the Amazon description has: "...includes as a bonus the complete text of Tolkien’s acclaimed lecture on Sir Gawain". I had a look in The Monsters and the Critics, and the lecture appears to be already have been fully reproduced. So, to my understanding this new HC edition reprints the chapter "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight", from MC, right...? Would be helpful if anyone who has received a copy could confirm this.
4 May, 2020
2020-5-4 8:37:30 AM UTC
I see Amazon have done their first predictable price drop (to £54). If they are true to form, it will drop once more and then rise.
4 May, 2020
2020-5-4 11:47:32 AM UTC

Morgan wrote:
Speaking about the "bonus content", the Amazon description has: "...includes as a bonus the complete text of Tolkien’s acclaimed lecture on Sir Gawain". I had a look in The Monsters and the Critics, and the lecture appears to be already have been fully reproduced. So, to my understanding this new HC edition reprints the chapter "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight", from MC, right...? Would be helpful if anyone who has received a copy could confirm this.

My copy is en route so I can't confirm and do not have my copy of Monsters to hand but from memory, in the foreword I believe CT mentions some elements he left out (temptation scenes?) and he replaces some original poem readings for some of Tolkien's own translations too? So the original lecture delivered was different that which was published in Monsters.
4 May, 2020
2020-5-4 2:23:28 PM UTC
Aside from a few illustrations and how the book is presented, nothing in this is "new" or exclusive.
4 May, 2020
2020-5-4 2:32:59 PM UTC

insurrbution wrote:
Aside from a few illustrations and how the book is presented, nothing in this is "new" or exclusive.

I don't have my copy yet, but can you clarify why you think this?
12345...15
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us