Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

By Stu
Home away from home

Show your uncommonly good condition editions

13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 3:54:29 AM UTC

Rules for the thread.

1. Must be at least 40 years old.
2. Must be in "uncommonly good condition", i.e. better than you would usually find.
3. No restored books or facsimile jackets

I've started here with a couple off the shelf, but I'll dig out some more as and when I have time to photo

For starters, LoTR 11/9/8 and The Hobbit '66, '67, '68

228_609ca2dc49b10.jpg 4032X3024 px

228_609ca2f019de3.jpg 4032X3024 px
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 4:36:11 AM UTC
Love it... hope these qualify:

All 1st/1sts.

Tree and Leaf looks like it has a faded spine but that's just the lighting, it's unfaded. When I bought it I found that it had two jackets, one on top of the other, and the top one had protected the one underneath keeping it in next to new condition (I posted about that, some may recall).

Two Towers is a review copy.

Looking closely at all of these it's not hard to find small flaws, but I think they would still be considered as 'uncommonly good condition'... if not, fight me!

4451_609cabc6cf56a.jpg 3072X2780 px

4451_609cabc6d09fd.jpg 3024X3165 px
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 4:44:50 AM UTC
Noice. I do remember your post about the two jackets -- that was an uncommonly lucky find!
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 5:30:43 AM UTC
My 1963 Lord of the Rings Deluxe Box-set, was really happy with the condition of the box.

The Two Towers
looks in worse condition than the other books, but nearly all the copies I have seen look like this and this is still a bit of a mystery!

10_609cb956956e6.jpg 1620X1080 px

10_609cb95695b14.jpg 1620X1080 px

10_609cb95695eed.jpg 1620X1080 px
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 6:06:50 AM UTC
Nice books all around. That said, I'm not the one who usually slobbers over stuff, but Stu's LotR set is amazing and Hobbitses are oh so pretty.
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 6:44:49 AM UTC
First impression Longman's (except the one on the far right, which is a reprint). All boxed up now (except one) so legacy photo from a previous thread...

228_609ccae14d509.jpg 1960X984 px
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 6:57:16 AM UTC
Show-off thread.
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 7:19:28 AM UTC

Khamûl wrote:

Show-off thread.

Aka jealousy thread ;)
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 7:56:26 AM UTC

Berelach wrote:

Khamûl wrote:

Show-off thread.

Aka jealousy thread ;)

My LoTR is probably what was used as the source for the logo part of the pocket LoTR set. At least HarperCollins asked me for scans when they were thinking about doing a set based on the 1st editions and I obliged. I like to think it's the case, anyway.
13 May, 2021
2021-5-13 10:33:39 AM UTC
That LotR looks amazing!

Nothing too rare at my end but happy with the condition of my copies of Sil and UT:

205_609d00a8094c3.jpeg 3024X4032 px

205_609d00a80a7b4.jpeg 4032X3024 px

205_609d00a80b5d1.jpeg 4032X3024 px

205_609d00a80c184.jpeg 4032X3024 px

205_609d00a80cecd.jpeg 4032X3024 px
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us