TolkienGuide.com
Powered by Collectors Since 2006
Sign In
TolkienGuide.com
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
(Nominated for 2026 Tolkien Society Award)
-
Guide to Tolkien Calendars
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...2425262728...69
9 Oct, 2021
2021-10-9 7:43:24 PM UTC
I managed to buy the trade edition in an english bookshop in Paris this afternoon.
The book itself is shrinkwrapped and housed in a blue protective cardboard box featuring the Gate of Durin, which is really nice !

It is printed by Rotolito, and the paper is really nice, not to thick, but not to thin either, with a matt touch, and very soft. The text block edges are red, but this colour is not as garish as the promotional pictures which make one think. It's a dark red which seems to me very close of the top stain colour of the first editions.

The original Tolkien's manuscript of the Ring verse has been used and this is a really great idea I think.
There is a special intro written by W.G. Hammond and C. Scull regarding the choices made for the illustrations.
Each original jacket designed by Tolkien has been displayed facing each title page for all of the three parts.

Bellow a couple of pictures, hope you enjoy !
Gallery

4888_6161ecbb451e0.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ecc99fde5.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ecd65e491.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ece529243.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ed913a12a.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161eda62a1a1.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161edc117bae.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161edd745fff.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161edeb5dee8.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161edfbcdf87.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ee5be183b.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ee7137223.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ee83cb816.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ee97632b3.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161eed895929.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161eee4a489a.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161eef9c30b9.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ef0c31606.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ef1d44b51.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ef586bfb6.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161ef6d6002d.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161efc53aeeb.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161efdb262ab.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161efef4e7fd.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161f006eb11a.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161f02206b9c.jpg 4128X2322 px

4888_6161f0363c9fe.jpg 4128X2322 px
9 Oct, 2021
2021-10-9 7:52:47 PM UTC
Thanks for this, the book looks very resplendent.

Does it have the two Notes on the Text or have they been replaced by Wayne and Christina's introduction about the images used?
9 Oct, 2021
2021-10-9 8:05:00 PM UTC

Trotter wrote:

Thanks for this, the book looks very resplendent.

Does it have the two Notes on the Text or have they been replaced by Wayne and Christina's introduction about the images used?

No it does not have the Note on the Text, just the Note on the illustrations which is an excerpt of the Art of the Lord of the Rings, and the Forward to the Second Edition.
9 Oct, 2021
2021-10-9 8:31:33 PM UTC
For those in Germany and Austria the deluxe is currently €110.99 on Bucher.

https://www.buecher.de/shop/science-fi ... /detail/prod_id/62660231/

And in the cart if you use the voucher code TREU2021 there is also another 12% off.

I have used them a lot and their service is excellent.
9 Oct, 2021
2021-10-9 8:43:49 PM UTC
I have added them to the list at the start of this thread, thanks
9 Oct, 2021
2021-10-9 9:28:20 PM UTC
Those who found the colors too aggressive should be reassured.
The edition is gorgeous
9 Oct, 2021
2021-10-9 9:47:06 PM UTC
For those who may be wondering: the tengwar (early, pre-publication, and different) following the English text of the Ring verse read (in English): "One ring to rule them all one ring to bind them one ring to bring them all and in the darkness bind them in the land of mordor where the shadows lie". There are many, many differences between this tengwar mode and the mode Tolkien later employed for English.
10 Oct, 2021
2021-10-10 3:01:15 AM UTC
The tengwar in Ring Verse and Doors of Durin still has typos :(
10 Oct, 2021 (edited)
2021-10-10 4:05:47 AM UTC

zionius wrote:

The tengwar in Ring Verse and Doors of Durin still has typos :(

It is a very slow process getting changes made to the published Lord of the Rings.

I would suggest trying to publish the issues in something like Tolkien Studies, which is peer reviewed.

That would add some weight to the corrections being made. You would also need to create high quality artwork of the correct images for the publishers to use.
10 Oct, 2021
2021-10-10 4:47:19 AM UTC

Trotter wrote:



It is a very slow process getting changes made to the published Lord of the Rings.

I would suggest trying to publish the issues in something like Tolkien Studies, which is peer reviewed.

That would add some weight to the corrections being made. You would also need to create high quality artwork of the correct images for the publishers to use.

Thanks, I've been considering that! Though it doesn't seem to fit Tolkien Studies, perhaps a short note in Mallorn or Beyond Bree.
1...2425262728...69
Jump to Last
All original content © by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us