Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

By Jabmon
Just popping in

Hardback version of The Tolkien Reader

6 hours ago
2025-5-14 3:15:15 PM UTC

Greetings,

Does anyone know if a hardback version of The Tolkien Reader exists?

I borrowed a friends copy of this book a while back ago and ended up losing it :(. I can't seem to remember if the book was a paperback, hardback or library binding. She says that her copy was a hardback binding. I remember what the cover art looks like, but I am having a hard time finding a hardback version of this publishing. I am having a hard time finding even a picture of a hardback publication of this book and am starting to doubt if one exists.

So, I am hoping that someone on this forum might have any knowledge about this or can answer my question above. I will attach a photo of the cover art from the book I borrowed.

**Bonus points** - I have found real photos (not just stock images) of almost every publication of this book from 1966 to current via ebay listing and other sites. Most of them being published by Ballantine Books. The only one I can not find much information on is the "Bt Bound" library binding publication of this book. ISBN:9780808508748 (ISBN10: 0808508741). Does anyone have a version of this book or know if the library binding is of harder material?

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated

The Tolkien Reader


$22.58 Blackwell's (book) - Availability: Unknown


Any help on this would be much appreciated! I would love to replace the book I lost with the exact version/publication.

Cheers!

6194_6824b253897d6.png 219X349 px
6 hours ago
2025-5-14 3:32:04 PM UTC
I have never seen a hardback edition of Reader. This website at least says the ISBN you noted is also a paperback edition:

https://www.librarycat.org/lib/jmc_cndk8/item/187919500

Many of the writings in Reader are also collected in other Tolkien anthologies like Poems and Stories and Tales from the Perilous Realm, which have hardback editions. Are you sure it wasn't one of those?

Hope this helps!
5 hours ago (edited)
2025-5-14 4:32:11 PM UTC
Covercraft/Perfection Learning did a Hardcover Rebind with it's own unique ISBN - 9780756910723

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated

The Tolkien Reader

San Val (1986-11-01)


$20.88 Bookshop.org (USA Only) - Availability: Click to check
$Unknown Blackwell's (hardback) - Availability: Unknown
$22.45 Amazon.com (Library Binding) - Availability: Now
€24.27 Amazon.de (Bibliothekseinband) - Availability: Now



11_6824c57a613e3.jpg 1505X2008 px

11_6824c57a61661.jpg 1505X2008 px

11_6824c57a616b3.jpg 2560X1920 px

11_6824c57a618ec.jpg 1505X2008 px
4 hours ago
2025-5-14 5:48:52 PM UTC
Thanks for the replies!

The cover art from both Tales from the Perilous Realm, Poems and Stories and The Del Rey publication of The Reader does not match what I borrowed. I also know the one I read had both The Homecoming of Beorhtnoth Beorhthelm's Son and The Adventures of Tom Bombadil in it.

I'm sure it must have been some publication of The Tolkien Reader. I am wondering if there were any special publications of it for a box set or edition? Most of what I can pull up about editions of this book are that they were mostly paperback. With the exception of the Del Rey publication.

These two sites show the Original Publication (1966) with the title the book in an oval bubble top of cover. Another Publication from the 70's with the title written across the top (no oval drop). A 1970's-1980's Library binding of the book that has a yellow back drop. The Del Rey Publication. And a BT Bound library binding publication from 1999.

https://www.goodreads.com/work/edition ... the-tolkien-reader?page=3
https://books.infosec.exchange/book/62234/editions

Again, maybe the version of the book I'm thinking of never existed as a hardback or I have slipped into another reality, creating a Mandela Effect.

Here is a picture (Via someone's reddit post) showing some different variants of the book. The one I borrowed looked like the book that is circled. But this is a Ballantine Books publication with softback binding from the 80's(?). Curious if the BT Bound Library Binding exists or if the above sites are incorrect.

Cheers

6194_6824d7717c03f.png 724X967 px
4 hours ago
2025-5-14 5:56:19 PM UTC
There was never a Ballantine hardcover, but library services (eg Permabound) would take paperbacks and rebind them into longer lasting hardcover format with the paperback cover art showing. Likely that is what you had.
Jump to Last
All original content © by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us