TolkienGuide.com
Powered by Collectors Since 2006
Sign In
TolkienGuide.com
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
(Nominated for 2026 Tolkien Society Award)
-
Guide to Tolkien Calendars
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

Festival Art and Books still claiming HarperCollins used forged Christopher Tolkien signatures

6 hours ago (edited)
2026-6-27 8:59:59 PM UTC

Obviously the price here is as absurd as the repeatedly debunked claims.

Hardcover. Condition: As New. Dust Jacket Condition: As New. First Edition. 1977 First edition with £4.95 on the flap indicating the UK edition. These are now quite rare. Fine, unread book and jacket with red in spine title still as cover. Signed by author/ editor JRR Tolkien's son and literary executor Christopher Tolkien who passed in 2020. There is some confusion over his signature. While Harper Collins sold certain deluxe editions signed and numbered by Christopher Tolkien, they were in fact signed by an assistant or member of staff. Still "official" and collectable as from the publisher as special editions, but very unlikely his own real signature or that he ever touched the books. At his age he was far too old to be signing thousands of books as likely he had arthritis etc. We know this from other elderly authors we have known of similar age. This book was signed around 1977 in his known style at the time. We will guarantee this with our company COA. Note, it is rumoured a film could be made of this book, but we have seen nothing announced. This would not have been possible in the past, but is possible now. The Amazon film series is part based on stories in the Silmarillion. There is a different international version with no UK price on the front flap and other features. Our opinion is the condition of the book matters most to the value, especially when most modern books suffer fading to the jacket spine colours. Nearly all the value is in the condition of the dust jacket. For a free copy of our Tolkien book collector guide, please ask. Signed by Author(s).

On the one hand, he states categorically: " they were in fact signed by an assistant or member of staff."
And then he contradicts himself: "very unlikely his own real signature"

So which is it, categorically signed by someone else, or (just) unlikely signed by Tolkien?


Previous discussion where Mark Faith has made these false claims before: https://www.tolkienguide.com/modules/n ... t_id=18578#forumpost18578
Gallery
image/png (1894 x 1356 px)
Uploaded by The late Stu on 27 Jun, 2026

Caption:

Title:
Screenshot-2026-06-28-at-8.58.15 AM.png
6 hours ago
2026-6-27 9:05:54 PM UTC
Worse than AI-generated misleading...
6 hours ago
2026-6-27 9:08:43 PM UTC
There's so much confusing phrasing and other misleading information in this listing, I agree.

My interpretation of what he is saying is - *this* book is signed by Christopher Tolkien. *HarperCollins* editions published much more recently were (he claims, I disagree) not signed by Christopher.

6 hours ago
2026-6-27 9:35:31 PM UTC

Urulókë wrote:

There's so much confusing phrasing and other misleading information in this listing, I agree.

My interpretation of what he is saying is - *this* book is signed by Christopher Tolkien. *HarperCollins* editions published much more recently were (he claims, I disagree) not signed by Christopher.


Oh, he is definitely saying that, but when discussing the limited editions, he hedges his bets by saying (without caveat) they are signed by an assistant and then immediately follows up with "unlikely" to be signed by Christopher Tolkien about those same editions. Making it clear he has absolutely no idea.
1 hour ago (edited)
2026-6-28 1:51:46 AM UTC
Dogfark (Mark Faith) seems to always be thinking of ways to make whatever snake oil he’s selling at the moment seem better than it really is so that his victim will pay his predatory asking price. While at the same time he seems to always try to sow discord and doubt amongst the Tolkien community to his advantage. If he can get one collector to doubt what they have so they will buy his BS, then his time and effort will have been worth it to him.

Much like Saruman There’s not a single true statement in all his flowery language here as much as he tries to make it seem so. His greatest fear is that a potential buyer will come here and ask about one of his listings. And I hope they continue to do so.
Jump to Last
All original content © by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us