I dont know if anyone saw this one yet...
http://www.ebay.com/itm/HOBBIT-first- ... m2a1c6bcd09#ht_500wt_1203
THE HOBBIT first edition!!! For only 50$
OH! Wait! It's not the Hobbit and definitely it's not in good shape :P
http://www.ebay.com/itm/HOBBIT-first- ... m2a1c6bcd09#ht_500wt_1203
THE HOBBIT first edition!!! For only 50$
OH! Wait! It's not the Hobbit and definitely it's not in good shape :P
Yeh, serious bidders only --on an auction where I can't even get the book title right! The Hobbit/LotRs --same difference...
BH
BH
http://www.ebay.ca/itm/TOLKIEN-MIXED- ... Media&hash=item4164f55578
And so why isn't saul and his legions of lawyers coming down on this like the wrath of god?
And so why isn't saul and his legions of lawyers coming down on this like the wrath of god?
Hi Red,
Good question - though the estate would have to come down on the seller, not Saul & co - the astute follower will have noticed that they have even removed Tolkien from their own business name (Middle-earth Enterprises, used to be Tolkien Enterprises). http://www.middleearth.com/about.html
In wrangling with the Estate over the years, it is clear that they do not have rights to anything "Tolkien".
Good question - though the estate would have to come down on the seller, not Saul & co - the astute follower will have noticed that they have even removed Tolkien from their own business name (Middle-earth Enterprises, used to be Tolkien Enterprises). http://www.middleearth.com/about.html
In wrangling with the Estate over the years, it is clear that they do not have rights to anything "Tolkien".
The Estate are not going after people using Shire in their name but Enterprises (Saul & Co) are, FITS look out.
Nearly everyone in England, Scotland, and Wales have lived in an area called a shire for at least 1000 years
Nearly everyone in England, Scotland, and Wales have lived in an area called a shire for at least 1000 years
Khamul wrote:
Apart from nearly every word in those two books he wrote...
BH
And there you have it - the word "Tolkien" does not appear in those two books, much to their chagrin. (They used "Tolkien Enterprises" and "Tolkien Quest" books, and... for years, until they got in trouble over it).
Yeh, the trouble is everything Middle-earth Enterprises license is, as they state, based on "Tolkien works" --& they own "exclusive worldwide rights to motion picture, merchandising, stage and other rights in certain literary works of J.R.R. Tolkien including The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit." Making them remove "Tolkien" from their name is total pedantry, in the grand scheme of things (--if that's what happened). Peter Jackson's films aren't based on any old Lord of the Rings and any old Hobbit --they're based on J. R. R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit. Whether The Tolkien Estate like this connection, or not, is immaterial --the connection exists.
BH
BH
33
1965