Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

12
13 May, 2009
2009-5-13 1:07:55 PM UTC
Not one to pass up the chance of a freebie!
13 May, 2009
2009-5-13 1:45:13 PM UTC
What do you guys think of this negative review?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/bo ... .R.R.-Tolkien-review.html
13 May, 2009
2009-5-13 4:28:55 PM UTC
Mark Sanderson is the one who should be flogged.
13 May, 2009
2009-5-13 8:36:18 PM UTC
I think this requires a post where I'm not grumbling about something or being generally negative??? Happy Thursday, everyone!
13 May, 2009
2009-5-13 11:09:42 PM UTC
I did like the "flogging a dead Norse" turn of phrase. The reviewer also captured a bit of the positive flavor in Tolkien's verse. I think the only real valid point to take away from this particular reviewer is that this book will not appeal to the same part of the brain as the PJ films did - big shock there.
14 May, 2009
2009-5-14 6:20:54 PM UTC
Always in for a free book
I have received the deluxe editon just a week, but I haven't got time to read it... I have almost examinations, you see, so Tolkien has to make (a little) way for some time...
Is it good? (the book Sigurd and Gudrún, I mean)

By the way, thanks HoughtonMifflin!
14 May, 2009
2009-5-14 8:12:51 PM UTC
The story is terrific! I have always been a fan of the old legends, including the Sigurd/Siefried sagas. I am afraid that many people may be turned off from this book, especially if they come to it seeking more Middle Earth. However, true Tolkien fans will enjoy it greatly, as it reveals more of the influences and ideas behind Tolkien concepts.
20 May, 2009
2009-5-20 7:52:34 PM UTC
Thanks to the German Tolkien Society, I found a German review in the top German newspaper: "Even to the great cry of vengeance". This is a serious and positive review, even though it starts out by stating that Tolkien's retelling of the Edda came from the same impulse as fanfic by readers of J.K. Rowling and Stephenie Meyer and as Jules Verne's continuation of Edgar Alan Poe's The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket as Le Sphinx des glaces, Goethe's continuation of Alois Schikaneder's Magic Flute and Ariosto's continuation of Matteo Maria Boiardo's Orlando Inamorato.
23 May, 2009
2009-5-23 5:51:49 PM UTC
Please, add me to the giveaway!

Even if it would have been thath kind of retelling, it will be nice. I have read Le Sphinix des glaces (The green ray?, I think that was how it was translated to Spanish) and Orlando Mad (?), illustrated by Gustave Dore. And they are good, Tolkien wrote/told (?) that if he would have read Ariosto's Orlando, he wouldn't have liked it; I never agreed with him... a bit like Inferno by Dante.
24 May, 2009
2009-5-24 10:03:56 AM UTC
Alas, I left my standard copy on a train last weekend. Luckily, though, I had my emergency backup deluxe copy to read

- wellinghall
12
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us