Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...1415161718...23
18 Nov, 2022
2022-11-18 9:43:05 PM UTC
Alan's picture of the Elves at the forge puzzles me further. The ring-shaped object on the coals is very large. The male figures are doing understandable things -- one is operating a bellows, one is using tongs. But what is the Elf-woman doing? Honestly, it looks like she is maybe sprinkling a pinch of salt on a jumbo bagel.

And the woman in the background appears to be grating something, like a clove of garlic perhaps, so that I almost wondered if Alan's idea was to show them taking a break for lunch and see if anyone noticed. Can someone explain -- ?
18 Nov, 2022
2022-11-18 11:36:30 PM UTC

Dale Nelson wrote:

Alan's picture of the Elves at the forge puzzles me further. The ring-shaped object on the coals is very large. The male figures are doing understandable things -- one is operating a bellows, one is using tongs. But what is the Elf-woman doing? Honestly, it looks like she is maybe sprinkling a pinch of salt on a jumbo bagel.

And the woman in the background appears to be grating something, like a clove of garlic perhaps, so that I almost wondered if Alan's idea was to show them taking a break for lunch and see if anyone noticed. Can someone explain -- ?

The "bagel" is a crucible, not a ring. You can't just put the metal into the coals. It isn't clear what the person in the background is doing, even looking at a higher resolution image, but I'd imagine it is a polishing stone, probably.

228_6378169a8ce3c.png 1922X988 px
18 Nov, 2022
2022-11-18 11:48:27 PM UTC
Thanks! What would you suggest that the Elf-woman in the foreground is doing? My first thought was that maybe she was inscribing a rin, but that doesn't really fit the image.
18 Nov, 2022
2022-11-18 11:55:22 PM UTC

Dale Nelson wrote:

Thanks! What would you suggest that the Elf-woman in the foreground is doing? My first thought was that maybe she was inscribing a rin, but that doesn't really fit the image.


I don't think so. From the hand detail it looks like she has a pinch of something that she is adding to the crucible, so probably adding another bit of ore to be smelted to get the right alloy. The image just shows the hand with pinched fingers. There isn't anything more than that.

228_63781b9317401.png 1238X1098 px
19 Nov, 2022
2022-11-19 12:17:03 AM UTC
Stu! Good to hear from you ?
19 Nov, 2022
2022-11-19 12:37:53 AM UTC
Welcome back Stu.
19 Nov, 2022
2022-11-19 2:28:25 AM UTC
She’s sprinkling fairy dust. How else do you think the elfs made their rings magic? ?
19 Nov, 2022
2022-11-19 2:39:27 AM UTC
Stu thank god you’re back
19 Nov, 2022
2022-11-19 8:11:58 PM UTC
Thanks northman, Philomythos, Mr. Underhill. I wouldn't say back, but I'll probably chip in from time to time if there is something I actually know about - which happens occasionally. I'm a renowned expert on the bagel and garlic approach to ring forging.
21 Nov, 2022
2022-11-21 10:48:32 PM UTC
Just FYI Alan has told me his compositional thoughts making this painting but I am waiting for him to confirm that I can post them publicly. ?
1...1415161718...23
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us