Tolkien Collector's Guide
signed?
By garm

signed?

Sep 9, 2013

Seller: tobyp (810)
Ended Sep 14, 2013
$1,999.00
[0 Bids]
what does the group think of this item?

eBay Item #231048745457
Sep 9, 2013
Signature looks fine to me. Price seems really high (by at least a factor of four to my mind).
Sep 10, 2013
I suppose so. I agree about the price, too.
Feb 20, 2014
(edited)
Hello

A friend recently sent me this photo and asked if I had a clue about the possible language that it was written in. It is in a 1950's Hobbit, and he makes no claim as to who wrote it, but have a look. A lot of the letters are made just as J.R.R. Tolkien wrote them. Anyone able to unscramble, translate, or offer any thoughts on this very interesting item.

Regards,

dunedain

125_53065460b9e80.jpg 980X866 px
Feb 22, 2014
(edited)
I've stared at this for quite awhile, trying to figure out whether Tolkien inscribed it, and what it might say. I've reached no firm conclusions, but will say:

1) I think this could very well have been inscribed by Tolkien. Some of it seems uncharacteristic, but that could be explained by, e.g., having to write while holding the book, etc.; but other details (that final "s", if that's what it is; the "o") are pretty striking.

2) At first I thought it might be written in Tolkien's "New English Alphabet", but I now lean away from that. Instead, I think that the first latter may be ƕ, the "hv-digraph" found frequently in Gothic; and that the last letters might be "dolts" (or "dolīs" or even "dolis"). IF so (and this is a big "if"), the inscription MIGHT be intended as a Gothic, or otherwise-early-Germanic, translation of the name "Tolkien" (< German Tollkühn, 'stupid-clever', 'stupid-brave', 'fool-hardy'). But if so, I can't offer a source or etymology of the initial half of the name, since nothing suitable resembling "ƕara" (if that's what it says) is attested in Gothic (which admittedly doesn't mean much, since Gothic is very sparsely attested compared to most other early Germanic literary languages.)

In all, a very interesting puzzle. I'll keep thinking about this one!

Carl
Feb 24, 2014
Thanks Carl,

I would agree that the last bit is "olts", or at least looks just like the way he wrote. I've attached a sample of his writing, photoshopped the letters together for fun one day. The 's' looks very like his, as well as the 'o' and 't' even with the changes in writing in script.
Feb 24, 2014
Here is the attachment...

609_530b575d21fed.jpg 633X469 px
Mar 21, 2014
It's now up on eBay:
eBay Item #181356865066

BH
Jump to Last