11 Apr, 2023
2023-4-11 11:36:19 PM UTC
Hello everyone, this is my first post here on the forum but not my first time reading.
Does anyone know how many prints the dark grey HM (US) version of the 50th anniversary edition is up to by now? Does it mirror the UK reprints?
I have the same question for the children of Hurin deluxe edition, apparently the HM print is less then the UK in reprints, likely from having an initial larger number of books printed, or am I way off course assuming so? The HM version seems harder to find in the sense that it seems to be priced higher then the UK version.
I'm trying to figure out these tings to better understand the market as I am looking to buy a first edition of them both but wish to understand the market a bit better first, it's a bit of a job being quite a few years and reprints behind.
Especially the HM Lord of The Rings 50th one seems to be priced all over the place and hard to find first editions of.
12 Apr, 2023
2023-4-12 10:08:04 AM UTC
Thank you for the info!
Looks like getting hold of first editions of the HM books will be harder then the UK versions.
Even the non signed children of Hurin first prints seems to be quite pricey compared to others, not yet able to find a stated first edition copy of HM Lord of The Rings for sale.. onwards digging!
13 Apr, 2023
2023-4-13 6:21:26 PM UTC
Just snagged a US copy of CoH first edition on ebay for $70 which seemed like a decent deal, so one down one to go but unable to find any first edition of the HM lotr anywhere. Does anyone have a ballpark what to expect price wise? I'm seeing everything from fifty to well over a hundred dollars for the 50th anniversary HM lotr on the second hand market, but unable to find any listing or info specifically pointing to the first edition.
13 Apr, 2023
2023-4-13 6:49:00 PM UTC
That's interesting that your 50th has the $85 price tag overlaid on it - I've not seen that before, both copies that I bought (a 1st at release and a reprint much later) just had the $100 printed price on them (but that's not what I paid, of course).
If I recall correctly, the "50th" blue edition was in print up until the illustrated edition came out in 2021, so there are likely very plentiful "new" copies still at retailers.
13 Apr, 2023
2023-4-13 6:55:34 PM UTC
Thanks again for your response. I think $70 was a fair price, slightly puzzled over the ones I see asking well over one or even several hundred for unsigned not even first edition HM CoH copies. LOTR looks like it's gonna take some more time tracking down but hopefully it has not over doubled or tripled in price like the recent Folio limited set I keep seeing in my searches sometimes over $3000!
20 Mar, 2024
2024-3-20 1:15:07 AM UTC
For all those no doubt living on the edge of their seats with no sleep since I made this post, I found a first edition first print of the HMH 50th anniversary lotr.
This was surprisingly hard to find, is there any way to see how many copies was in the first run of the first edition? I refuse to believe it was not in the tens of thousands, being such a high profile US release back in 2004.
18 Sep, 2025
2025-9-18 4:34:11 AM UTC
I just recently picked up the gray HM single volume "deluxe" version. I probably overpaid and wasn't careful about edition, but I ended up with the 1st printing. Nice! I have no idea how many there were, but I've had some experiences with 2000s HMH printings where it seemed hard NOT to find a 1st printing (e.g. the larger illustrated LOTR 3-book sets). It seems like they may have liked to print a ton of copies early? I could also be totally off base.
I also just received a copy of the "Deluxe" HC single volume LOTR, and it's a 17th printing from an Indian printer I hadn't heard of. Interestingly, it has the 2014 intro to text by
Findegil. I wonder if it really has the updated text with the 2014 emendations? I'll look another time and can post a photo if anyone is interested... Logically, the removal of the 50th Anniversary label on the spine may coincide with a text change and the new 2014 note. The quality of binding and paper is really quite nice; 17th for me is a very high quality and readable printing. One very small gripe is that the slipcase is a tad tight. I wonder if this is a side effect of having a nice openable binding.