LanceFormation wrote:

Aelfwine wrote:

I pointed Harper Collins to my (now itself out-of-date) list of corrections (https://elvish.org/errata/NoMe-Errata.pdf), but I don't know whether any of them have been incorporated (nor do I yet have a copy of the paperback to check).

Carl

I did some spot checking (about a dozen random items from the list) and it appears the corrections have been incorporated. Especially “Mind-pictures” ?

(Added: I actually checked the first 32 entries of the errata thru this entry: “p. 112, n. 7: Correct the alignment of the left margin.” Everything checks out as incorporated.)

Aelfwine I had time so I finished checking the entire errata you pointed to. I found that every item in the list checks out as corrected except:

p. 426 s.v. Gil-galad: after “78,”, insert “81,”; after “347,” insert “359, 361,”.

Looks like they did incorporate 359 and 361, but missed 81. And I double checked page 81 and Gilgalad is in the text.

So please take my effort as just a quick pass…I may have missed something.

Lance

Thanks!

I just received my UK (HarperCollins) paperback. It does have page 81 for Gil-galad.

It seems that the UK and US paperbacks have officially diverged ?

Urulókë wrote:

I just received my UK (HarperCollins) paperback. It does have page 81 for Gil-galad.

It seems that the UK and US paperbacks have officially diverged ?

Egads!

I have updated my list of Nature of Middle-earth errata. Please spread the word and link as appropriate.

https://elvish.org/errata/NoMe-Errata.pdf

Thanks,

Carl